Thoughts on Christian Theology and Pastoring

The Machine

Paul Kingsnorth’s book offers a sobering assessment of the technological age we are living in.

If you’ve ever had the suspicion that technology might be doing something bad to us, that the problem might be deeper than the way we use our devices, and that this bad thing has been going on for a long time, then you’ll be interested in what Paul Kingsnorth has to say in his book Against the Machine: On the Unmaking of Humanity.

A friend at church recommended the book to me, so I picked it up thinking it would help me with an article I was writing on the topic of technology. It turned out to be much more than what I expected.

In this book, Kingsnorth seeks to identify a force that is unraveling and uprooting culture, and he calls this force “The Machine.” It is, strictly speaking, not technology, but the large-scale manifestation of an all-consuming greed within each human, made concrete by technological progress, and perpetuated by the myth that “progress” is inevitable and good. This gives “The Machine” a truly spiritual power as it acts as a god we worship, trust, and to which we offer sacrifices.

You may not agree with Kingsnorth’s conclusions, but it’s hard to deny that he’s describing something both dreadful and real.

The Machine, he says, is disintegrating the values that undergirded older societies:

  • “Past. Where a culture comes from, its history and ancestry.
  • People. Who a culture is. A sense of being ‘a people.
  • Place. Where culture is. Nature in its local and particular manifestation.
  • Prayer. Where a culture is going. Its religious tradition, which relates to God or the gods.”

For Kingsnorth, his native England epitomizes the ravages of the machine. “Like much of the West, [England] currently seems to be in a kind of freeform cultural collapse. . . . The English long ago gave up on the religion that formed their nation and their values—Christianity. They are one of the most urbanised nations on earth. . . . Our memory of the land, and our understanding of it, is almost entirely dead. . . . We have largely forgotten our history.”

In place of Past, People, Place, and Prayer, the Machine offers:

  • “Science. Where we come from. Science can offer us a non-mythic version of this story, and assert a claim as to the [measurable] nature of reality.
  • The Self. Who we are. The highest good is to serve the self and ensure its longevity.
  • Sex. What we do. Both the highest means of sacral pleasure and, through public expressions of ‘sexuality,’ an affirmation of individual identity.
  • The Screen. Where we are going. The screen is both our main source of distraction from reality and the interface by which we are directed into the coming post-human reality of the Machine.”

I appreciate that Kingsnorth recognizes the deeply spiritual and even theological nature of these commitments (he calls them “a kind of catechism for the Machine age”). It fits with the time-tested observation—a Biblical truth—that there is a God-shaped vacuum in the heart of every human, and that we will fill it with whatever we possibly can. When we seek to fill that void with something as vast, tentacled, and enchanting as “The Machine,” the result is inevitable: it gobbles us alive.

“When we forget the proper direction to aim our prayers,” Kingsnorth warns, “we will end up aiming them at the ultimate idol: our own image, reflected back at us in our little black screens. We will be kings and queens of a deceptively free world, parading through a liturgy of the self.”

The offer sounds too familiar. Can we detect the sibilant strains of: “You will be like gods, knowing good and evil”?

How terrifying. How true.


Subscribe to jonathanthrelfall.com

You'll get solid content delivered weekly.

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading